Chapter 4 - Theory
2. Risk assessment and management plans
Cyber risk assessment is a crucial part of maintaining cybersecurity on ships, helping to identify, evaluate, and mitigate risks associated with both IT and OT systems onboard (International Maritime Organization, 2017). This process involves systematically evaluating potential threats, vulnerabilities, impacts, and likelihoods, and then determining appropriate risk mitigation measures. The risk assessment is not a one-time event but rather an ongoing process that needs to be revisited periodically to keep up with evolving threats and technologies.
In this context, a structured approach is essential, comprising four main phases: pre-assessment activities, ship assessment, debrief and reporting, and the manufacturer’s debrief. Each phase builds upon the previous one to ensure a comprehensive and effective evaluation of risks. Additionally, third-party risk assessments can provide specialized expertise, helping organizations gain a deeper understanding of their cybersecurity posture.
This section outlines the key elements involved in a risk assessment process, from initial preparation through to detailed reporting and ongoing collaboration with system manufacturers. It provides a roadmap for shipowners and operators to safeguard their assets and ensure the resilience of their cybersecurity systems.
Risk Assessment: Understanding the Relationship Between Influencing Factors
A comprehensive risk assessment begins only after evaluating threats, vulnerabilities, impacts, and likelihood. It is an ongoing process that should be revisited regularly to keep findings up to date. The risk is determined by multiplying the likelihood of an event by its potential impact.
The Four Phases of Risk Assessment
Phase 1: Pre-assessment Activities
Risk assessments apply to both new and existing ships, including second-hand vessels entering the fleet. Cyber risk assessments are complex and may require third-party assistance. Pre-assessment activities include:
- Reviewing IT and OT system documentation to assess potential impact, such as using the CIA model.
- Identifying key manufacturers of critical equipment based on risk.
- Establishing relationships with cybersecurity contacts at these manufacturers.
- Reviewing ship maintenance and support documentation.
- Examining contractual obligations for IT/OT maintenance.
Phase 2: Ship Assessment
The risk assessment systematically evaluates the system’s risks. It considers threats, vulnerabilities, likelihood, and impact by analyzing each system individually. For accuracy, knowledge of system functionality, data flows, and connections (both wired and wireless) is essential. This phase may require input from various company staff, equipment manufacturers, and external cybersecurity experts. Any system connection, such as a shared network printer, can become a vulnerability. Risk assessments are conducted for each system but should be approached holistically, taking into account interconnected systems and the cost-effectiveness of mitigation measures. The assessment may involve reviewing the configuration of all cyber infrastructure, including firewalls, routers, and other security technologies.
Phase 3: Debrief and Reporting
The final risk assessment document should be detailed and coherent, documenting how risks are assessed and mitigated. The process is iterative, with various mitigation measures evaluated to determine the optimal solution in terms of legal requirements, risk appetite, feasibility, and cost. For assessments conducted by third parties, the report typically includes:
- An executive summary of findings, recommendations, and the ship's security profile.
- Technical findings, including vulnerabilities and their potential impacts.
- A prioritized action list based on effectiveness, cost, and applicability.
- Supplementary data with technical details and penetration testing results.
- Appendices with a record of activities and tools used during the assessment.
Phase 4: Manufacturer’s Debrief
Once the shipowner reviews and assesses the findings, any critical issues may be forwarded to system manufacturers for mitigation. This collaboration helps identify appropriate remediation actions, ensuring a comprehensive solution to any vulnerabilities.