Chapter 7 - Theory

2. IMO Guidelines and Resolution MSC.428(98)

Overview of IMO Resolution MSC.428(98) and its Requirement to Incorporate Cyber Risk Management into the Safety Management System (SMS)

The International Maritime Organization (IMO) has recognized the growing threat of cyber risks to the maritime sector. To address these challenges, IMO Resolution MSC.428(98) was adopted, mandating that cyber risk management be integrated into the Safety Management System (SMS) by January 1, 2021. The resolution emphasizes that shipowners and operators must assess cybersecurity risks and implement measures to protect their vessels and onboard systems.

Key aspects of IMO Resolution MSC.428(98) include:

  • The requirement for shipping companies to incorporate cybersecurity into their existing SMS.
  • A risk-based approach to identifying and mitigating cyber threats.
  • The importance of continuous monitoring, updating, and improving cybersecurity practices.
  • The recognition of existing industry guidelines, such as those from BIMCO, IACS, and the U.S. Coast Guard (BIMCO et al., 2020; IACS, 2021).
How to Ensure Compliance with IMO’s Cybersecurity Recommendations

Compliance with IMO’s cybersecurity guidelines requires:

  1. Risk Assessment: Identifying potential cyber threats to onboard systems and evaluating their impact (IMO, 2017a).
  2. Implementation of Mitigation Strategies: Applying security measures, such as firewalls, access controls, and intrusion detection systems (Sowmya & Anita, 2023).
  3. Crew Training and Awareness: Educating personnel on cybersecurity best practices, phishing attacks, and secure system usage.
  4. Incident Response Planning: Establishing a framework for detecting, responding to, and recovering from cyber incidents.
  5. Regular Audits and Updates: Ensuring SMS policies reflect the latest threats and industry developments.

Cybertechnologies have become essential to the operation and management of numerous systems critical to the safety and security of shipping and protection of the marine environment. In some cases, these systems are to comply with international standards and Flag Administration requirements. However, the vulnerabilities created by accessing, interconnecting or networking these systems can lead to cyber risks which should be addressed. Vulnerable systems could include, but are not limited to:

  • Bridge systems
  • Cargo handling and management systems
  • Propulsion and machinery management and power control systems
  • Access control systems
  • Passenger service and management systems
  • Passenger facing public networks
  • Administrative and crew welfare systems
  • Communication systems

The distinction between information technology and operational technology systems should be considered. Information technology systems may be thought of as focusing on the use of data as information. Operational technology systems may be thought of as focusing on the use of data to control or monitor physical processes. Furthermore, the protection of information and data exchange within these systems should also be considered.

While these technologies and systems provide significant efficiency gains for the maritime industry, they also present risks to critical systems and processes linked to the operation of systems integral to shipping. These risks may result from vulnerabilities arising from inadequate operation, integration, maintenance and design of cyber-related systems, and from intentional and unintentional cyberthreats.

Threats are presented by malicious actions (e.g. hacking or the introduction of malware) or the unintended consequences of benign actions (e.g. software maintenance or user permissions). In general, these actions expose vulnerabilities (e.g. outdated software or ineffective firewalls) or exploit a vulnerability in operational or information technology. Effective cyber risk management should consider both kinds of threat.

Vulnerabilities can result from inadequacies in design, integration and/or maintenance of systems, as well as lapses in cyber discipline. In general, where vulnerabilities in operational and/or information technology are exposed or exploited, either directly (e.g. weak passwords leading to unauthorized access) or indirectly (e.g. the absence of network segregation), there can be implications for security and the confidentiality, integrity and availability of information. Additionally, when operational and/or information technology vulnerabilities are exposed or exploited, there can be implications for safety, particularly where critical systems (e.g. bridge navigation or main propulsion systems) are compromised.

Effective cyber risk management should also consider safety and security impacts resulting from the exposure or exploitation of vulnerabilities in information technology systems. This could result from inappropriate connection to operational technology systems or from procedural lapses by operational personnel or third parties, which may compromise these systems (e.g. inappropriate use of removable media such as a memory stick).

These rapidly changing technologies and threats make it difficult to address these risks only through technical standards. As such, these Guidelines recommend a risk management approach to cyber risks that is resilient and evolves as a natural extension of existing safety and security management practices.

In considering potential sources of threats and vulnerabilities and associated risk mitigation strategies, several potential control options for cyber risk management should also be taken into consideration, including amongst others, management, operational or procedural, and technical controls.

Application

These guidelines are primarily intended for all organizations in the shipping industry and are designed to encourage safety and security management practices in the cyber domain.

Recognizing that no two organizations in the shipping industry are the same, these Guidelines are expressed in broad terms to have a widespread application. Ships with limited cyber-related systems may find a simple application of these Guidelines to be sufficient; however, ships with complex cyber-related systems may require a greater level of care and should seek additional resources through reputable industry and Government partners.

Elements of cyber risk management 

For the purpose of these Guidelines, cyber risk management means the process of identifying, analyzing, assessing, and communicating a cyber-related risk and accepting, avoiding, transferring or mitigating it to an acceptable level, considering costs and benefits of actions taken to stakeholders.

The goal of maritime cyber risk management is to support safe and secure shipping, which is operationally resilient to cyber risks.

Effective cyber risk management should start at the senior management level. Senior management should embed a culture of cyber risk awareness into all levels of an organization and ensure a holistic and flexible cyber risk management regime that is in continuous operation and constantly evaluated through effective feedback mechanisms.

One accepted approach to achieve the above is to comprehensively assess and compare an organization's current, and desired, cyber risk management postures. Such a comparison may reveal gaps that can be addressed to achieve risk management objectives through a prioritized cyber risk management plan. This risk-based approach will enable an organization to best apply its resources in the most effective manner.

These Guidelines present the functional elements that support effective cyber risk management. These functional elements are not sequential – all should be concurrent and continuous in practice and should be incorporated appropriately in a risk management framework:

  • Identify: Define personnel roles and responsibilities for cyber risk management and identify the systems, assets, data and capabilities that, when disrupted, pose risks to ship operations.
  • Protect: Implement risk control processes and measures, and contingency planning to protect against a cyber-event and ensure continuity of shipping operations.
  • Detect: Develop and implement activities necessary to detect a cyber-event in a timely manner.
  • Respond: Develop and implement activities and plans to provide resilience and to restore systems necessary for shipping operations or services impaired due to a cyber-event.
  • Recover: Identify measures to back-up and restore cyber systems necessary for shipping operations impacted by a cyber-event.

These functional elements encompass the activities and desired outcomes of effective cyber risk management across critical systems affecting maritime operations and information exchange and constitute an ongoing process with effective feedback mechanisms.

Effective cyber risk management should ensure an appropriate level of awareness of cyber risks at all levels of an organization. The level of awareness and preparedness should be appropriate to roles and responsibilities in the cyber risk management system.

Best practices for implementation of cyber risk management 

The approach to cyber risk management described herein provides a foundation for better understanding and managing cyber risks, thus enabling a risk management approach to address cyberthreats and vulnerabilities. For detailed guidance on cyber risk management, users of these Guidelines should also refer to Member Governments' and Flag Administrations' requirements, as well as relevant international and industry standards and best practices.

Additional guidance and standards may include, but are not limited to:

  • The Guidelines on Cyber Security Onboard Ships produced and supported by ICS, IUMI, BIMCO, OCIMF, INTERTANKO, INTERCARGO, InterManager, WSC and SYBAss.
  • Consolidated IACS Recommendation on cyber resilience (Rec 166).
  • SO/IEC 27001 standard on Information technology – Security techniques – Information security management systems – Requirements. Published jointly by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC).
  • United States National Institute of Standards and Technology's Framework for Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity (the NIST Framework).
  • IAPH Cybersecurity Guidelines for Ports and Port Facilities.