Chapter 7 - Theory
3. Cyber Insurance and Liability Considerations
3.2. Liability Considerations and Cyber Breaches
Maritime operators must thoroughly evaluate liability risks associated with cyber breaches. Failure to comply with cybersecurity regulations such as IMO and GDPR can result in significant penalties, legal action, and reputational damage. Cyberattacks that cause financial or operational harm to third parties may lead to legal claims from customers, partners, or stakeholders, including those related to supply chain disruptions, cargo delays, or environmental hazards. Additionally, contractual agreements such as charter contracts, insurance policies, and vendor arrangements often include specific cybersecurity obligations, and non-compliance can trigger financial penalties or disputes. Data breaches involving crew or passenger information pose further risks, potentially resulting in lawsuits, compensation claims, and regulatory scrutiny under data protection laws. Finally, organizations that fail to implement adequate cybersecurity measures may be held liable for negligence. Demonstrating due diligence through proactive security practices and adherence to industry standards is essential to mitigating these risks (IACS, 2021).
Regulatory Responsibility
With the introduction of modern data protection regulations such as GDPR (EU), CCPA (US), and LGPD (Brazil), organizational responsibility for safeguarding personal data has significantly increased. Companies must implement appropriate technical and organizational measures, report data breaches within 72 hours as required by GDPR, and provide individuals with the ability to access, modify, and delete their personal information.
Contractual and inter-organizational responsibility
Modern companies often work with dozens of external providers of IT, cloud, or payment services. Each such relationship requires a data processing agreement (DPA) and a clear definition of the scope of responsibility.
A data processing agreement compliant with the GDPR must include:
- An explanation of who the data controller is
- An explanation of who the data processor is
- The subject and duration of data processing
- The nature and purpose of data processing
- The type of personal data entrusted and the categories of persons to whom this data relates
- A definition of the obligations and rights of the data controller
- A statement by the processor indicating their obligations
Models of Shared Responsibility
In cloud computing, the shared responsibility model operates, in which responsibility for security is shared between the service provider and the client. The provider is responsible for the physical security of data centers, hardware infrastructure, and the basic software layer (e.g., system updates). The client is responsible for managing access to systems, configuring security, updating software running on rented resources, as well as securing data transmitted and stored in the cloud. This division of responsibility requires close cooperation between both parties and a precise understanding of the scope of responsibilities—often a challenge in multi-cloud environments. Incorrect assumptions about competences can lead to security gaps for which neither party formally feels responsible. Therefore, it is crucial to write detailed documentation and use tools to monitor the level of security and compliance with established procedures.
Indemnification Clauses
Indemnification clauses are becoming more common in B2B contracts, i.e., provisions requiring one party to cover damages, financial losses, and legal costs of the other party resulting from cyber incidents. Such clauses play an important role in managing contractual risk, especially in environments where multiple parties share responsibility for shared systems and data. Indemnification clauses can include:
- Reimbursement of costs resulting from regulatory and legal proceedings
- Coverage of the costs of notifying customers about data leaks
- Refund of business interruption costs
- Coverage of contractual penalties for end customers
To be effective, they must be precisely formulated, indicate specific cases in which they come into force, and clearly divide the scope of liability. They are often the subject of negotiations already at the stage of concluding a framework agreement or tender. For insurers, having such clauses in contracts is also a positive signal about the maturity of the organization in risk management, which may affect the amount of the premium or the availability of insurance cover.
Cybersecurity in the Maritime Sector
The maritime industry, as part of critical infrastructure, must take cyber threats into account in a special way. Automation of port processes, digital navigation systems, integration of supply chains with cloud solutions, and dependence on remote communication expose the sector to attacks that can lead to:
- Downtime of ports and ships
- Disruptions in global logistics
- Threats to human and environmental safety
Policies aimed at the maritime sector often include extended coverage, which includes:
- Disruption of port operations and vessel downtime
- Cyberattacks on on-board systems (e.g., ECDIS, AIS, GMDSS)
- Disruption of data transmission and loss of connection with headquarters
- Costs of alternative transport arrangements as a result of IT failure
- Liability to customers and contractors for delays
- Coverage of costs of inspections and security audits after an incident
The Role of the IMO in Regulating Maritime Cybersecurity
In response to the growing threats, the International Maritime Organization (IMO) has developed guidelines for managing cyber risk at sea. Since 1 January 2021, under IMO resolution MSC.428(98), every ship subject to the SOLAS convention (including merchant and passenger ships) must demonstrate that it manages cyber risk as part of a safety management system (ISM Code). This means that shipowners and operators are required to:
- Identify threats and vulnerabilities in IT and OT systems
- Implement preventive and incident response procedures
- Train crews in cyber hygiene
- Test security measures and update systems regularly
Fulfilling these requirements is increasingly becoming a condition for obtaining cyber insurance for shipowners and a key element of insurers’ risk assessments.