Chapter 7 - Theory
5. Cyber Risk Management and the Safety Management System (SMS)
5.3. Integrating Cyber Risk into the SMS
The integration of cyber risk into an SMS involves embedding cybersecurity into the existing structure and culture of safety and risk management. The process aligns well with the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) model used in ISM systems.
Plan: Identify and Assess Cyber Risks
- Risk Assessment: Perform a comprehensive cyber risk assessment for onboard and shore-based systems
- Asset Mapping: Inventory all IT and OT systems, including interfaces between them (e.g., ECDIS connected to a LAN with internet access)
- Threat Modelling: Identify threats (e.g., malware via USBs, remote attacks) and associated vulnerabilities
- Impact Analysis: Evaluate how a cyber event could impact safety, navigation, or cargo integrity.
Tools like FMECA (Failure Mode, Effects, and Critically Analysis) or BowTie analysis are used to visualize the potential pathways of cyber threats.
Do: Implement Cybersecurity Controls
- Technical Controls:
- Network segmentation (e.g., isolating OT from IT networks)
- Access controls and authentication (e.g., MFA)
- Patch management schedules for shipboard software
- Antivirus and endpoint protection solutions
- Data encryption and secure backups (especially for logs and navigation data)
- Organizational Controls:
- Crew training and cyber hygiene programs
- Restricted USB and removable media policies
- Clear reporting lines for cyber incidents
- Cybersecurity protocols embedded in voyage planning and port call procedures
Check: Monitor and Audit Cyber Measures
- Performance Monitoring: Use key performance indicators (KPIs) like number of blocked intrusion attempts or phishing simulations passed
- Internal Audits: Include cybersecurity controls in regular SMS audits
- Log Review: Regularly review access logs, IDS alerts, and system logs for anomalies
- Vulnerability Scanning: Conduct periodic scans of onboard and shore-connected systems
The effectiveness of cyber controls should be verified during ISM internal audits and management reviews.
Act: Respond and Improve
- Incident Response Plan (IRP): Ensure cyber incidents are part of the SMS emergency preparedness plan. This includes clear roles, escalation paths, and communication templates.
- Drills and Exercises: Include cyber scenarios in drills (e.g., ECDIS outage due to malware).
- Corrective Actions: Following any incident or near-miss, conduct a root cause analysis and update controls as needed.
- Continuous Improvement: Regularly review and improve cybersecurity measures based on lessons learned and emerging threats.